اجعلنا صفحة البداية RSS خدمة Add to favorite Facebook Twitter


Oscar nod for protest film cheers Palestinians
Published Tuesday 29/01/2013 (updated) 02/02/2013 20:06
Font- Font+
A poster for the Oscar-nominated documentary "5 Broken Cameras"
is displayed at a theater in Ramallah January 28, 2013.
(Reuters/Mohamad Torokman)

RAMALLAH (Reuters) -- Oscar-nominated documentary "5 Broken Cameras" screened for Palestinians for the first time on Monday, leaving locals hopeful that their struggle with Israel for land and statehood will gain a global audience.

The low-cost film is based on five years of amateur camera work by journalist Emad Burnat as he documented weekly protests against land seizures by Israeli forces and Jewish settlers in his village of Bilin in the occupied West Bank.

Neighbors are killed in the protests and demolition equipment mars the landscape while the filmmaker captures his infant son's rapid loss of innocence, heralded by his first words: "wall" and "army."

"This is a film for those who were martyred. It's bigger than me and bigger than Bilin. More than a billion people follow the Oscars and they will know our struggle now," Burnat said after the viewing.

His work will compete at next month's Oscar ceremony against four other films, including a documentary called "The Gatekeepers" that looks at the decades-old Middle East conflict through the eyes of six top former Israeli intelligence bosses.

Although the perspective is very different, both movies share a surprisingly similar message -- the Israeli occupation of the West Bank is morally wrong and must end.

Burnat's film received a standing ovation at its premier in Ramallah, the Palestinians' administrative capital, with the audience excited to see their seemingly endless conflict splashed on the big screen.

"The film shows the whole world what occupation is. It wiped the happiness off the boy's face at too young an age. This has been the experience for all of us," said taxi driver Ahmed Mustafa, who brought his wife and child to the viewing

"It's not all bad though. It shows that there is progress, there are victories, and that our cause is still alive and moving," he said.

In 2007, Israel's High Court ruled that the separation barrier built on Bilin lands was illegal and ordered it rerouted, cheering activists. The ruling was finally implemented in 2011, but the protests continue.

Israeli co-direction

Humble villagers in black-and-white chequered Palestinian scarves and smartly dressed city dwellers shared the same visceral reaction to scenes in the film that are much chronicled but seldom appear in feature-length film.

A shot of olive trees reduced to glowing embers after being torched by Jewish settlers coaxes an audible gasp from viewers.

"Oh God!" said one man.

But as Burnat's camera captures defiant chants in the protagonists' village accent, or rocks being hurled at fleeing Israeli jeeps, ecstatic applause filled the hall.

The film was co-directed by an Israeli activist and filmmaker, Guy Davidi. This close association has led some people to classify 5 Broken Cameras as an Israeli movie and it was rejected by a Morocco film festival for this reason.

However, Burnat said it had been shown in Iran and other Middle Eastern countries and denied that the joint production reflected any meaningful "normalization" of relations between Israel and the Palestinians.

"(Davidi) is a solidarity activist who came to the village to show his support. He was shown our material and agreed to help. This doesn't represent Israeli-Palestinian collaboration," Burnat said.

But the film's action shows many examples of cooperation between Israeli solidarity activists and locals.

An Israeli photographer gives Burnat one of his five cameras, which are progressively shot or crushed in protests over the years, giving the film its name, and Israeli solidarity activists are shown helping to plan protests in Hebrew.

"Working jointly with an Israeli doesn't diminish this work, it enhances it," Palestinian student Amira Daood told Reuters.

"They're not all against us. Some are opposed to what Israel is doing and the movie demonstrates that," she said.
1 ) Isn't this an ISRAELI-PALSTINI / AN co-production???
29/01/2013 16:40
only good things come from Arab-Jewish CO-OPERATION!!!!

2 ) Mel / USA
29/01/2013 18:14
The best"Oscar"is to END THE ILLEGAL ISRAELI OCCUPATION of legal Palestinian land/water,& the illegal collective punishment of GAZA!Can U win that 'Oscar' Mr.Nobel POTUS?Or,are U still 2 concerned re: the"Zionist vote"?Just stop the tax-free FMF annual cash dumps($5 BILLION p.a.), grants,loans,subsidies,WEAPONS,to Zionist-led,rogue-nuclear Israel!Our FOREIGN POLICY's a WMD!Our ECONOMY's a MESS! 47 MILLION US citizens IN POVERTY,& U STILL GIFT EVERY ISRAELI 1,000 US tax dollars,p.a.,per capita!!

3 ) Brian Cohen / Israel
29/01/2013 18:16
May this Illegal Occupation End ,then All will have Peace

4 ) Me / The country of struggle
29/01/2013 20:50
It was great watching this documentary on the struggle of Palestinians. I always thought that our case would never be heard worldwide, however, after watching this film and now that it's going to the Oscars I have a very strong feeling that this will make a huge difference.

5 ) Mel / USA
29/01/2013 21:37
#3)Brian:Here!Make yourself some coffee,sit down for an hour or so,&remind yourself of the MODERN HISTORICAL FACTS! Learn the difference 'tween Judaism &political/ideological ZIONISM!The latter is destructive to the former,& the State of Israel.UK/UN knew decades ago that it was ALL A HUGE mistake,to CONFUSE colonial Zionism with global Judaism.And that Zionism was a PERPETRATOR!Now the USG makes the same criminal,FATAL,mistake again,since 1950's!ENUF!

6 ) Paolo / USA
30/01/2013 01:50
................... can't wait to see it in a theatre or buy it on dvd. film is breathing and loving & a universal bridge of communication. it is a necessary 1st step in bringing down walls, halting bull dozers & opening the eyes of all to existing abuses. i applaud this effort to tell a reality as it is, NO MATTER WHO is behind it.

7 ) gabi / australia
30/01/2013 03:57
Hello - someone else is using Brian Cohen's name?????

8 ) ian / australia
30/01/2013 09:40
I suspect #3 isn't really Brian, what with the eccentric capitals, bad grammar and incompetent typing, but I hope it is.
Name Country
Note: Comments will be reviewed for appropriate content. Click here for more details.


Freedom Theater play takes new look at Nativity Church siege
Rachel Corrie play returns to NY stage
Palestine Marathon defies Israeli restrictions on movement

Close Next Previous
All Rights Reserved © Ma'an News Agency 2005 - 2014